What are your predictions of GS, FB, BJK, etc. overall players' ratings in FIFA 10?

[Salt The Fries]

I'm trying to be realistic.

Here's mine:

Galatasaray

Leo Franco - 79
Sabri Sarioglu - 76, star moves 4/5
Servet Cetin - 80, star moves 3/5
Gokhan Zan - 77, star moves 2/5
Hakan Balta - 77, star moves 3/5

Mustafa Sarp - 76, star moves 3/5
Ayhan Akman - 77, star moves 4/5
Elano Blumer - 83, star moves 5/5

Arda Turan - 85, star moves 5/5
Milan Baros - 79, star moves 4/5 (or 5/5)
Abdul Kader Keita - 81, star moves 5/5

--

Ufuk Ceylan - 74
Aykut Ercetin - 71

Caner Erkin - 73, star moves 4/5
Alparslan Erdem - 71, star moves 4/5
Emre Asik - 75, star moves 1/5
Emre Gungor - 74, star moves 3/5
Semih Kaya - 69(70), star moves 2/5
Serkan Kurtulus - 67, star moves 3/5
Ugur Ucar - 74 - star moves 3/5

Mehmet Topal - 76, star moves 2/5
Tobias Linderoth - 75, star moves 3/5
Baris Ozbek - 74, star moves 4/5

Aydin Yilmaz - 74, star moves 4/5
Serdar Eylik - 70, star moves 3/5
Harry Kewell - 80, star moves 5/5

Shabani Nonda - 76, star moves 3/5 (or 4/5)

Fenerbahce:

Volkan Demirel - 81

Gokhan Gonul - 78, star moves 4/5
Diego Lugano - 83, star moves 3/5
Fabio Bilica - 73, star moves 2/5
Roberto Carlos - 77, star moves 5/5

Cristian Baroni - 78, star moves 3/5
Emre Belozoglu - 79, star moves 4/5
Andre Santos - 81, star moves 5/5
Alex de Souza - 84, star moves 5/5
Kazim-Kazim - 76, star moves 5/5

Daniel Guiza - 80, star moves 4/5

--

Volkan Babacan - 72

Gokcek Vederson - 70, star moves 3/5
Bekir Irtegun - 72, star moves 2/5
Onder Turaci - 75, star moves 2/5
Deniz Baris - 73, star moves 2/5

Ugur Boral - 74, star moves 4/5
Mehmet Topuz - 80, star moves 4/5
Ozer Hurmaci - 77, star moves 5/5
Abdülkadir Kayalı - 71, star moves 4/5

Deivid de Souza - 75, star moves 3/5
Semih Senturk - 79, star moves 3/5

Besiktas JK:

Rustu Recber - 76

Ekrem Dag - 75, star moves 3/5
Matteo Ferrari - 78, star moves 3/5
Tomas Sivok - 76, star moves 2/5
Ismail Koybasi - 77, star moves 4/5

Fabian Ernst - 79, star moves 3/5
Michael Fink - 75, star moves 3/5
Rodrigo Tello - 79, star moves 5/5
Serdar Ozkan - 78, star moves 5/5
Rodrigo Tabata - 79, star moves 4/5

Bobo - 79, star moves 3/5

--

Hakan Arikan - 73

Ibrahim Uzulmez - 72, star moves 3/5
Ibrahim Toraman - 76, star moves 3/5
Ibrahim Kas - 75, star moves 3/5
Erhan Guven - 70, star moves 3/5
Ridvan Simsek - 73, star moves 3/5

Ugur Inceman - 70, star moves 2/5
Yusuf Simsek - 77, star moves 4/5
Erkan Zengin - 71, star moves 3/5

Filip Holosko - 81, star moves 5/5
Kahveci Nihat - 80, star moves 5/5
Mert Nobre - 77, star moves 3/5
Batuhan Karadeniz - 75, star moves 5/5

Do you think I'm unbiased?

Star moves is about fluency in dribbling and the ability to use these super-fancy moves. Below 4/5 is a competent level, but you can't use some of these super-fancy moves, 3/5 is average and Frank Lampard for example has 3/5.

[Musicá]

Originally Posted by Salt The Fries

I'm trying to be realistic.

Here's mine:

Galatasaray

Leo Franco - 77
Sabri Sarioglu - 74, star moves 4/5
Servet Cetin - 80, star moves 3/5
Gokhan Zan - 76, star moves 2/5
Hakan Balta - 77, star moves 3/5

Mustafa Sarp - 75, star moves 3/5
Ayhan Akman - 76, star moves 4/5
Elano Blumer - 82, star moves 5/5

Arda Turan - 82, star moves 5/5
Milan Baros - 79, star moves 4/5 (or 5/5)
Abdul Kader Keita - 80, star moves 5/5

--

Ufuk Ceylan - 74
Aykut Ercetin - 71

Caner Erkin - 73, star moves 4/5
Alparslan Erdem - 71, star moves 4/5
Emre Asik - 75, star moves 1/5
Emre Gungor - 76, star moves 3/5
Semih Kaya - 69(70), star moves 2/5
Serkan Kurtulus - 67, star moves 3/5
Ugur Ucar - 74 - star moves 3/5

Mehmet Topal - 73, star moves 2/5
Tobias Linderoth - 75, star moves 3/5
Baris Ozbek - 74, star moves 4/5

Aydin Yilmaz - 74, star moves 4/5
Serdar Eylik - 70, star moves 3/5
Harry Kewell - 78, star moves 5/5

Shabani Nonda - 75, star moves 3/5 (or 4/5)

Fenerbahce:

Volkan Demirel - 81

Gokhan Gonul - 77, star moves 4/5
Diego Lugano - 81, star moves 3/5
Fabio Bilica - 73, star moves 2/5
Roberto Carlos - 74, star moves 5/5

Cristian Baroni - 77, star moves 3/5
Emre Belozoglu - 79, star moves 4/5
Andre Santos - 79, star moves 5/5
Alex de Souza - 83, star moves 5/5
Kazim-Kazim - 77, star moves 5/5

Daniel Guiza - 79, star moves 4/5

--

Volkan Babacan - 72

Gokcek Vederson - 70, star moves 3/5
Bekir Irtegun - 72, star moves 2/5
Onder Turaci - 75, star moves 2/5
Deniz Baris - 73, star moves 2/5

Ugur Boral - 74, star moves 4/5
Mehmet Topuz - 80, star moves 4/5
Ozer Hurmaci - 77, star moves 5/5
Abdülkadir Kayalı - 71, star moves 4/5

Deivid de Souza - 75, star moves 3/5
Semih Senturk - 79, star moves 3/5

Besiktas JK:

Rustu Recber - 76

Ekrem Dag - 75, star moves 3/5
Matteo Ferrari - 78, star moves 3/5
Tomas Sivok - 76, star moves 2/5
Ismail Koybasi - 77, star moves 4/5

Fabian Ernst - 79, star moves 3/5
Michael Fink - 75, star moves 3/5
Rodrigo Tello - 79, star moves 5/5
Serdar Ozkan - 78, star moves 5/5
Rodrigo Tabata - 79, star moves 4/5

Bobo - 79, star moves 3/5

--

Hakan Arikan - 73

Ibrahim Uzulmez - 72, star moves 3/5
Ibrahim Toraman - 76, star moves 3/5
Ibrahim Kas - 75, star moves 3/5
Erhan Guven - 70, star moves 3/5
Ridvan Simsek - 73, star moves 3/5

Ugur Inceman - 70, star moves 2/5
Yusuf Simsek - 77, star moves 4/5
Erkan Zengin - 71, star moves 3/5

Filip Holosko - 79, star moves 5/5
Kahveci Nihat - 82, star moves 5/5
Mert Nobre - 77, star moves 3/5
Batuhan Karadeniz - 74, star moves 5/5

Didn't bother the rest

[Kink]

I dont do FIFA so cant really help you out. Im a PES fan even though 09 was complete rubbish.

[Finaslan]

we'll have to wait and see, I think they won't improve much though.

[Kink]

Yeah same, by the looks of it so far it seems like a polished version of 09. Heres to hoping though. They will get it right some day soon hopefully.

[Crysis101]

Originally Posted by Kink

Yeah same, by the looks of it so far it seems like a polished version of 09. Heres to hoping though. They will get it right some day soon hopefully.

Yeah, for example the crowd still looks 64 bit. I don't really see any big changes, PES10 on the other hand has this interesting card system that they're introducing. I think I'll just wait for the reviews.

[Salt The Fries]

^ Haven't you played the demo, you impetuous fool?

I instantly felt the different in every single nuance of the game, and I'm stoked for new FIFA!

[Zizou1905]

I think your being a bit too generous on our younger players, Semih Kaya will probably get something like a 58 or 60. I won't be surprised at all, if the ratings have hardly improved since last year. Arda will definately, be an 80+ this year though.

[Salt The Fries]

I wonder if they will put 4-3-3 as our main formation by default, if not then they are impetuous fools .

[Salt The Fries]

About our overall ratings, when writing them I was well aware how much given player got in 09 ...

Anyway, do you think GS is a better or not worse team than Marseille? If you think so, then I think my ratings are fair. I didn't abuse nor overrate anyone.

[Crysis101]

Yeah the handling feels a little more fine tuned and I think the team you pick won't be as important as skill level (I beat Barca 3-0 with Chicago). It feels more like a mod tbh.

I mean you could probably find some talented individuals who could up the textures, code the movement of the wall during the free kick and possibly code improved output on the control stick, there aren't really any "new game modes". Being an RPG gamer I like a bit of micro-management and looking at the vids the card system looks good. I have no idea how well PES will handle though.

[Zizou1905]

Nope, In fifa 09 Marseille was a little bit stronger their left defender sucked Taiwo is a beast tho. I just don't think that our younger unused players will get anything above a 60. Serdar Eyilik will probably be something like a 65, Aydin would be good if they finally gave him a 75 so thats a rating I agree with you on last year he got 69 or 70 I don't remember.

Anyway here are my ratings

Galatasaray

Leo Franco - 78
Sabri Sarioglu - 76, star moves 4/5
Servet Cetin - 80, star moves 3/5
Gokhan Zan - 75, star moves 2/5
Hakan Balta - 77, star moves 3/5

Mustafa Sarp - 73, star moves 3/5
Ayhan Akman - 74, star moves 4/5
Elano Blumer - 80, star moves 5/5

Arda Turan - 83, star moves 5/5
Milan Baros - 80, star moves 4/5 (or 5/5)
Abdul Kader Keita - 79, star moves 5/5

--

Ufuk Ceylan - 71
Aykut Ercetin - 71

Caner Erkin - 71, star moves 4/5
Alparslan Erdem - 69, star moves 4/5
Emre Asik - 70, star moves 1/5
Emre Gungor - 74, star moves 3/5
Semih Kaya - 65, star moves 2/5
Serkan Kurtulus - 63, star moves 3/5
Ugur Ucar - 70 - star moves 3/5

Mehmet Topal - 76, star moves 2/5
Tobias Linderoth - 75, star moves 3/5
Baris Ozbek - 73, star moves 4/5

Aydin Yilmaz - 72, star moves 4/5
Serdar Eylik - 70, star moves 3/5
Harry Kewell - 79, star moves 5/5

Shabani Nonda - 73, star moves 3/5 (or 4/5)

Fenerbahce:

Volkan Demirel - 80

Gokhan Gonul - 76, star moves 4/5
Diego Lugano - 82, star moves 3/5
Fabio Bilica - 72, star moves 2/5
Roberto Carlos - 74, star moves 5/5

Cristian Baroni - 77, star moves 3/5
Emre Belozoglu - 78, star moves 4/5
Andre Santos - 80, star moves 5/5
Alex de Souza - 83, star moves 5/5
Kazim-Kazim - 75, star moves 5/5

Daniel Guiza - 80, star moves 4/5

--

Volkan Babacan - 70

Gokcek Vederson - 70, star moves 3/5
Bekir Irtegun - 68, star moves 2/5
Onder Turaci - 71, star moves 2/5
Deniz Baris - 70, star moves 2/5

Ugur Boral - 73, star moves 4/5
Mehmet Topuz - 79, star moves 4/5
Ozer Hurmaci - 73, star moves 5/5
Abdülkadir Kayalı - 70, star moves 4/5

Deivid de Souza - 75, star moves 3/5
Semih Senturk - 79, star moves 3/5

Besiktas JK:

Rustu Recber - 75

Ekrem Dag - 75, star moves 3/5
Matteo Ferrari - 79, star moves 3/5
Tomas Sivok - 77 star moves 2/5
Ismail Koybasi - 75, star moves 4/5

Fabian Ernst - 79, star moves 3/5
Michael Fink - 75, star moves 3/5
Rodrigo Tello - 78, star moves 5/5
Serdar Ozkan - 75, star moves 5/5
Rodrigo Tabata - 74, star moves 4/5

Bobo - 79, star moves 3/5

--

Hakan Arikan - 71

Ibrahim Uzulmez - 70, star moves 3/5
Ibrahim Toraman - 77, star moves 3/5
Ibrahim Kas - 75, star moves 3/5
Erhan Guven - 70, star moves 3/5
Ridvan Simsek - 70, star moves 3/5

Ugur Inceman - 70, star moves 2/5
Yusuf Simsek - 76 star moves 4/5
Erkan Zengin - 71, star moves 3/5

Filip Holosko - 79, star moves 5/5
Kahveci Nihat - 82, star moves 5/5
Mert Nobre - 77, star moves 3/5
Batuhan Karadeniz - 75, star moves 5/5

Trabzonspor

Tony Sylva - 76
Tolga Zengin - 72

Egemen Korkmaz - 74
Rigobert Song - 73
Hrvoje Cale - 75
Remzi Giray - 68
Ferhat Oztorun - 69
Serkan Balci - 72

Gustavo Colman - 75
Alanzinho - 78
Tjikuzu - 73
Drago Gabric - 74
Baris Memis - 71
Selcuk inan - 73
Ceyhun Gulselam - 70
Zafer Yelen - 62
Ibrahim Yattara - 78

Umut Bulut - 75
Gokhan Unal - 77

c'mon bro, we need to be realistic there is no way that EA is going to give our players the recognition that they deserve but the big three will all certainly be 4 star teams which is good

[Salt The Fries]

Real and official stats of Galatasaray:

Leo Franco 78
Sabri Sarioglu 75
Servet Cetin 83
Gokhan Zan 77
Hakan Balta 74

Mustafa Sarp 70
Ayhan Akman 73
Elano Blumer 81

Arda Turan 81
Milan Baros 80
Abdul Kader Keita 81

these would be probably subs:

Ufuk Ceylan 65
Aykut Ercetin 72

Caner Erkin 71
Alparslan Erdem 70
Emre Asik 76
Emre Gungor 73
Semih Kaya 57
Serkan Kurtulus 60
Ugur Ucar 70

Mehmet Topal 77
Tobias Linderoth 74
Baris Ozbek 75

Aydin Yilmaz 70
Serdar Eylik 66
Harry Kewell 78

Shabani Nonda 76

I got them from data reviewer on EA Sports forum. Do you want me to ask about Besiktas JK, Fenerbahce or someone else ratings as well? Just tell me and I will ask him.

[ArdaTuran1905]

toooo low for sarp

[Finaslan]

go ahead an ask. btw if I remember correctly.. overall ratings aren't really that important.