bayern's 10 greatest players ever

[arminius]

who are the 10 best players in the history of this great club, here's my picks. 1.F.Beckenbauer 2.G.Mueller 3.L.Matthaeus 4.K.H Rummenigge 5.O.Kahn 6.S.Maier 7.P.Breitner 8.S.Effenberg 9.M.Scholl 10.M.Ballack This was'nt easy, it's a bit difficult comparing players in different positions against each other, i also left out guys like klinsmann coz he only played i think 2 seasons with them, also had to leave out other greats like andy brehme,uli hoeness and probably others iv'e overlooked, also ballack should move up the list as the years progress.

[nachi88]

who are the 10 best players in the history of this great club, here's my picks. 1.F.Beckenbauer 2.G.Mueller 3.L.Matthaeus 4.K.H Rummenigge 5.O.Kahn 6.S.Maier 7.P.Breitner 8.S.Effenberg 9.M.Scholl 10.M.Ballack This was'nt easy, it's a bit difficult comparing players in different positions against each other, i also left out guys like klinsmann coz he only played i think 2 seasons with them, also had to leave out other greats like andy brehme,uli hoeness and probably others iv'e overlooked, also ballack should move up the list as the years progress.

my top 10 list would be like this

1) Franz Beckenbauer
2) Sepp Maier
3) Gerd Muller
4) Lothar Mathaus
5) Karl Heinz Rumminige
6) Paul Breitner
7) Oliver Kahn
8) Michael Ballack
9) Stefan Effenberg
10) Jurgen Klinsmann

Jurgen has to be in the list, he won the uefa championship with them. also close rans would be mehmet scholl, thomas helmer, bixente lizarazu and roy makaay(if he stays for a few seasons more)

[arminius]

it's a great list of players, perhaps only schalke could top this.

[arminius]

i forgot to put a winking smiley face with that last post.

[nachi88]

i forgot to put a winking smiley face with that last post.
who would be in schalke top 10... hahaha
i dont know why u have such strong liking for shalke. take my word, they wont even finish second, werder, and vfb will finish ahead of them. bayern rule. ;) ( i didnt forget to put the smiley)

[nachi88]

damn we left out klaus augenthaler and Uli Hoeneß. i think we should now redo the whole top ten.

[PrAvI HrVaT]

i like the kovacs :thumbsup: but there old now :boo:

[nachi88]

i like the kovacs :thumbsup: but there old now :boo:

hey kovacs? in all time bayern bests??? no way

[PrAvI HrVaT]

hey kovacs? in all time bayern bests??? no way
i never said in the bests, i just said i like them.

[baggy]

Franz "Kaiser" Beckenbauer and Gerd "Phantom" Mueller are absolutely the best Bayern players ever!!!
The first a steady deffender, who had also good abilities to create actions and score himself. The second was a real phantom, you didn't listen about him during the match, he was hidden somewhere, waiting for the chance to come, but once it really came, he stroke. He didn't have dribling abilities, but he had a good sense knowing where the two posts stood, anywhere he was in the pitch, even when he was showing his back to those two posts!!!

[nachi88]

Now i redo my top 12, to accomodate for the one's I earlier missed.


1) Franz Beckenbauer
2) Sepp Maier
3) Gerd Muller
4) Lothar Mathaus
5) Karl Heinz Rumminige
6) Paul Breitner
7) Oliver Kahn
8) Michael Ballack
9) Uli Hoeness
10) Jurgen Klinsmann
11) Klaus Augenthaler
12) Stefan Effenberg

[karimi_nr1]

so you guys dont like ali daei in bayern..!! he was such a good player but i think he played much better when he played for herta berlin :rolling:

[RonaldoD08]

so you guys dont like ali daei in bayern..!! he was such a good player but i think he played much better when he played for herta berlin :rolling:

I think the best player is Ronaldo...ooopppsss...wrong thread...:D

NO I am joking (even though Ronaldo is the best).

I agree with baggy about Kaizer and Phantom but I would add Kahn to the top three. I mean Kahn has been the constant best player for Bayern for many years now...(it's pretty sad when your best player is the goalkeeper - like for juve - but what can you do if there is only one Real Madrid...lol)

I like Bayern (my team) in Bundesliga. Tschus guys...:D

[nachi88]

so you guys dont like ali daei in bayern..!! he was such a good player but i think he played much better when he played for herta berlin :rolling:

I agree, daei was better in hertha. In Bayern he didnt get much chance.

[santacruze]

I agree, daei was better in hertha. In Bayern he didnt get much chance.

I prefer change Ballack as Elber

[Chivu]

I'd actually put Ballack in the top 5

[ItalyFanNumero]

Well the best Bayern team ever was named as:

Maier;

Augenthaler, Schwarzenbeck, Beckenbauer, Breitner;

Scholl, Effenburg, Matthaus;

Rummenigge, Muller, Elber;

With honorable mentions of Max 'Gaberl' Gablonsky, Ludwig Goldbrunner, Conrad Heidkamp, Franz Krumm, Oskar Rohr, Wilhelm Simetsreiter, Jakob Streitle, Dieter Brenninger, Franz Roth, Werner Olk, Björn Andersson, Wolfgang Dremmler, Uli Hoeness, Dieter Hoeness, Branko Oblak, Rainer Zobel, Jean-Marie Pfaff, Raimond Aumann, Andreas Brehme, Norbert Eder, Ludwig Kögl, Hans Pflügler, Stefan Reuter, Olaf Thon, Roland Wohlfarth, Mario Basler, Dietmar Hamann, Thomas Helmer, Jürgen Klinsmann, Bixente Lizarazu, Thomas Strunz, Alain Sutter, Oliver Kahn, Michael Ballack, Willy Sagnol, Owen Hargreaves, Zé Roberto, Claudio Pizarro, Lúcio, Roy Makaay & Sebastian Deisler.

[Donschday]

Jurgen has to be in the list, he won the uefa championship with them. also close rans would be mehmet scholl, thomas helmer, bixente lizarazu and roy makaay(if he stays for a few seasons more)

Klinsmann shouldnt be in the list, winning the UEFA cup doesnt make you a big player. And Klinsmann played awfull in munich. Nah I dont want him in the top 10.

My top ten(no order):
Sepp Maier
Oliver Kahn
Klaus Augenthaler
Franz Beckenbauer
Paul Breitner
Stefan Effenberg
Lothar Matthäus
Mehmet Scholl (or Elber)
Gerd Müller
Karl-Heinz Rummenigge

[emode]

My top ten(no order):
Sepp Maier
Oliver Kahn
Klaus Augenthaler
Franz Beckenbauer
Paul Breitner
Stefan Effenberg
Lothar Matthäus
Mehmet Scholl (or Elber)
Gerd Müller
Karl-Heinz Rummenigge

Why didn't u put Ballack in the list? He was doing pretty good at Bayern until he moved to Chelsea that is...
In years to come i hope we can put Philipp Lahm, Bastian Schweinsteiger & Lukas Podolski in the list too.

[mutu310]

Klinsmann shouldnt be in the list, winning the UEFA cup doesnt make you a big player. And Klinsmann played awfull in munich. Nah I dont want him in the top 10.

My top ten(no order):
Sepp Maier
Oliver Kahn
Klaus Augenthaler
Franz Beckenbauer
Paul Breitner
Stefan Effenberg
Lothar Matthäus
Mehmet Scholl (or Elber)
Gerd Müller
Karl-Heinz Rummenigge

This is a good list. I'd take out Breitner or Augenthaler and leave Elber in though. My top 6 would be:

Beckenbauer
Mueller
Kahn
Effenberg
Scholl
Matthaeus

The rest, in my humble opinion, lack a bit behind.

[emode]

MY list would have to be:
1) Franz Beckenbauer
2) Gerd Muller
3) Lothar Mathaus
4) Sepp Maier
5).Karl Heinz Rumminige
6) Paul Breitner
7) Oliver Kahn
8) Jurgen Klinsmann
9) Uli Hoeness
10) Michael Ballack

[XGermanyFFanX]

1) Franz Beckenbauer
2) Sepp Maier
3) Gerd Muller
4) Lothar Mathaus
5) Karl Heinz Rumminige
6) Paul Breitner
7) Oliver Kahn
8) Michael Ballack
9) Stefan Effenberg
10) Jurgen Klinsmann