Scholl vs. Zidane

[FCBBarcaAjax]

I wrote somewhere, Scholl if is healthy can match Zidane, do you agree? If dont, why dont. Some people told me, there is no compasismetn betwen them. They both play in middle, both 30,32. Both have fantastic free kicks. Both use right foot(I think),...

[Sebi]

i think Scholl is a very good player and very important for Bayern. I like him very much, but i think comparing him with Zidane, is too much.

He has not that elegance and cannot do that tricks, Zidane can!

[gnlvagosov]

Scholl is good
Zidane is world class

[barça]

Originally posted by FCBBarcaAjax
Both use right foot(I think),...

As much as I hated to see it, ZZ's CL winning goal, was left footed.

ZZ is better.

[The Rule]

I can't believe this discussion is taking place,the only player in Germany who could be compared to ZIZIOU,is Rosicky,and that's onlt if he continues to develop the way he has.I think he might need to leave Dortmund to reach his full potential.A move to Liverpool would be ideal for him..........:D

[Sebi]

Originally posted by The Rule
I can't believe this discussion is taking place,the only player in Germany who could be compared to ZIZIOU,is Rosicky,and that's onlt if he continues to develop the way he has.I think he might need to leave Dortmund to reach his full potential.A move to Liverpool would be ideal for him..........:D

LOL, a move to Liverpool would be his end :D
But Rosicky is never so good, that he can be compared with zidane!

[The Rule]

Originally posted by Sebi
LOL, a move to Liverpool would be his end :D
But Rosicky is never so good, that he can be compared with zidane!

i'm obviously dealing with someone of great intelligence and knowledge her....:rolleyes:..........so i won't say anymore

[FCBBarcaAjax]

You mabe are actualy wright,...

[Sebi]

Originally posted by The Rule
i'm obviously dealing with someone of great intelligence and knowledge her....:rolleyes:..........so i won't say anymore

i was just joking!
if you can`t see smilies and understand no humor, i`m sorry for that!

[The Rule]

you didn't put a smilie in when you said that Rosicky "is never so good that he can be compared with Zidane!"

[Sebi]

Originally posted by The Rule
you didn't put a smilie in when you said that Rosicky "is never so good that he can be compared with Zidane!"

where do you live ?
Did you see all his weak games ?
I saw him very often playin`not very well, but i don`t see Zidane very often like him!

I think he can get a great soccer-player, but it`s to early to compare him with Zidane!

[The Rule]

Originally posted by The Rule
,the only player in Germany who could be compared to ZIZIOU,is Rosicky,and that's onlt if he continues to develop the way he has.

this is what i said.THAT HE COULD BE COMPARED TO ZIDANE IF HE CONTINUES TO IMPROVE.

But a biased Bayern fan like yourself probably doesn't rate anyone not at your club,even though the best defender(lucio),and striker(amoroso)in the Bundesliga don't play for Bayern.You lot have the best keeper in Kahn and Ballack is the best midfielder,but i wouldn't count on Ballack still being there next season if i was you.

[Sebi]

Originally posted by The Rule
this is what i said.THAT HE COULD BE COMPARED TO ZIDANE IF HE CONTINUES TO IMPROVE.

But a biased Bayern fan like yourself probably doesn't rate anyone not at your club,even though the best defender(lucio),and striker(amoroso)in the Bundesliga don't play for Bayern.You lot have the best keeper in Kahn and Ballack is the best midfielder,but i wouldn't count on Ballack still being there next season if i was you.

I´m sorry, i`m sorry!

that`s not true. I know that Lucio and Amoroso are one of the best players in the Bundesliga. But Amoroso is an asshole.... he`s a unfair player, so i don`t like him, but i know he`s good.

[barça]

Originally posted by The Rule
I can't believe this discussion is taking place

You know, Rule, you are right. Just look at the CL final goal, whenever there is a bit of doubt. (man, do I dislike that goal:) )

[tok87]

How can u compare players like Zidane vs Scholl :confused:

[FCBBarcaAjax]

amoroso was good last season, but on start of this season(vorrunde) he was only in porhepas 3 games good(since game with FCK). He loses ball a lot, just look the game with Bayern usw.

[The Rule]

Originally posted by tok87
How can u compare players like Zidane vs Scholl :confused:

he was probably drunk again

[TaLoNPoG]

Yeah Really they both are really good players why would u want to compare them two Scholl and Zidane are really good

[tok87]

Originally posted by TaLoNPoG
Yeah Really they both are really good players why would u want to compare them two Scholl and Zidane are really good

:rolleyes:

Scholl is good, but ZZ is a champion, thats a big difference.

[ItalianBoy]

School and Zz are 2 different type of players imo.
Zidane is more of an assist man, Scholes can run and score.

[TaLoNPoG]

I see what ur talkin about. Both playerz are good at what they do so why would u want to compare when they are completely different???

[- FAN -]

Scholl is a good player but I think Zidane is a bit better...by the way scholl is shorter than Zidane so do ya think the tallness affects the player? :)

[The Rule]

Originally posted by - FAN -
Scholl is a good player but I think Zidane is a bit better...by the way scholl is shorter than Zidane so do ya think the tallness affects the player? :)

They play the same position,as a playmaker between midfield and the strikers,Zidane is the best player in the world,Scholl's not even in the top 25,he'd be lucky to be in the top 50

[TaLoNPoG]

i believe the tallness of a player is a better quality because the taller the more effiecent of gettin the ball away from other players so i guess he is a bit better then Scholl. Although i saw Scholl in the WolrdCup other then Zidane. I dont know if Zidane was on the German National Team but i will say that i saw Scholl.

So i guess it will end up in a tie both players are good and need to be better :)

[- FAN -]

Originally posted by TaLoNPoG
i believe the tallness of a player is a better quality because the taller the more effiecent of gettin the ball away from other players so i guess he is a bit better then Scholl. Although i saw Scholl in the WolrdCup other then Zidane. I dont know if Zidane was on the German National Team but i will say that i saw Scholl.

So i guess it will end up in a tie both players are good and need to be better :)
Well, Sholl didn't play in the last world cup cause he was injured :) :)

[TaLoNPoG]

Really???????? I thought i saw him play agianst the American team i guess my eyes decieved me lol. Butanyways it is the tallness of players that will porbably win the game, the American commentators at the WorldCup said that one of the main reasons that America lost is that most of the Germans were 6 inches taller then the American players so i guess it really does matter of bein tall. :) :P

[- FAN -]

as u said specially for the German national team but what the heck I hate them :annoyed:

[The Rule]

Originally posted by TaLoNPoG
. I dont know if Zidane was on the German National Team but i will say that i saw Scholl.

So i guess it will end up in a tie both players are good and need to be better :)

eh yeah Zidane was in goals for germany.

Zidane is the best player in the world and i doubt if he could be any better,what planet do you live on????a tie???/yeah good lad

[The Rule]

and as for this tallness crap,Maradona was only about 5 foot 7 inches and he was the greatest of all time.height has ***k all to do with it

[Mpenza]

Originally posted by - FAN -
Well, Sholl didn't play in the last world cup cause he was injured :) :)

So far i know, Scholl DIDNT want to play in tje world cup.....